The Hudson River Derby returns in knockout football as New York Red Bulls host New York City FC in the Round of 16 of the 2026 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup. The match is scheduled for April 30, 2026 at 00:00 GMT+0 at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey. This local derby always carries extra intensity, and with a place in the quarter-finals on the line, both sides will be fully motivated.
No specific referee information has been released yet. The game will be broadcast on Paramount+ and CBS Sports Network. Red Bulls will look to use their home advantage at the compact venue with a capacity of 25,000, while NYCFC aims to advance past their rivals in a competition where surprises are common.
Betting Tips and Match Insights
Before diving into the numbers, it is essential to understand the current context of this matchup. Both teams have shown inconsistent results in MLS recently, making this cup tie particularly open. New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC prediction today must consider home form, defensive vulnerabilities, and the historical edge in derbies. The high-scoring nature of recent encounters between these sides adds another layer to the betting evaluation. Expect a competitive battle where tactical discipline and individual quality will decide the outcome.
New York Red Bulls Results
New York Red Bulls have been involved in several high-scoring games lately, showing both attacking potential and defensive fragility. Their results reflect a team capable of scoring but struggling to keep clean sheets consistently. Here is their recent form across competitions:
| Date | Competition | Matchup | Result | W/L |
| 26.04.26 | MLS | FC Cincinnati vs New York Red Bulls | 2-0 | L |
| 23.04.26 | MLS | New York Red Bulls vs DC United | 4-4 | D |
| 18.04.26 | MLS | CF Montreal vs New York Red Bulls | 4-1 | L |
| 16.04.26 | US Open Cup | New York Red Bulls vs Pittsburgh | 3-1 | W |
| 12.04.26 | MLS | Inter Miami vs New York Red Bulls | 2-2 | D |
Red Bulls have managed just one win in their last five matches. They have conceded 12 goals across these games while scoring 10, highlighting major issues at the back. The draw-heavy pattern and heavy defeats on the road suggest they must improve defensively if they want to progress in the cup. Home support at Sports Illustrated Stadium will be crucial for them to stabilize.
New York City FC Results
New York City FC have also experienced mixed fortunes, alternating between heavy defeats and occasional high-scoring victories. Their away form remains a concern heading into this derby. Recent results look as follows:
| Date | Competition | Matchup | Result | W/L |
| 25.04.26 | MLS | CF Montreal vs New York City FC | 1-0 | L |
| 23.04.26 | MLS | New York City FC vs FC Cincinnati | 4-4 | D |
| 19.04.26 | MLS | New York City FC vs Charlotte | 1-2 | L |
| 15.04.26 | US Open Cup | Westchester SC vs New York City FC | 2-5 | W |
| 12.04.26 | MLS | Vancouver Whitecaps vs New York City FC | 2-0 | L |
NYCFC have won only one of their last five matches and have been leaky defensively, conceding in most games. The high goal count in several fixtures indicates an open style that could lead to another goal-filled derby. Their ability to score freely is an asset, but defensive organization away from home remains a clear weakness.
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC Head-to-Head (Last 5 Matches)
The rivalry has produced consistently entertaining and high-scoring games in recent seasons. New York City FC have had the upper hand in many of the latest encounters. Here are the last five meetings:
| Date | Competition | Matchup | Result |
| 28.09.25 | MLS | New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC | 2-3 |
| 17.05.25 | MLS | New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls | 2-0 |
| 24.11.24 | MLS | New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls | 0-2 |
| 29.09.24 | MLS | New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC | 1-5 |
| 19.05.24 | MLS | New York City FC vs New York Red Bulls | 2-1 |
NYCFC have won three of the last five derbies, often with multiple goals. Red Bulls have struggled to contain NYCFC’s attacking players in recent years, especially away from home, though home games tend to be more competitive.
Predicted Lineups for New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC
As the Hudson River Derby approaches, both teams are expected to field their strongest available squads for this important U.S. Open Cup Round of 16 clash. While official lineups will be confirmed closer to kick-off, here are the most likely starting XI based on recent matches, tactical preferences, and current form of both sides.
New York Red Bulls possible starting lineup:
Horvath (GK), Ilenic (DF), Nealis (DF), Parker (DF), Bungi (DF), Donkor (MF), Mehmeti (MF), Edelman (MF), Tolkin (MF), Cowell (FW), Hall (FW)
New York City FC possible starting lineup:
Freese (GK), Gray (DF), Martins (DF), Trewin (DF), O’Toole (DF), Parks (MF), O’Neill (MF), Ojeda (MF), Marañón (MF), Fernández (MF), Mercau (FW)
Key Match Factors to Consider
Several important elements will shape this Round of 16 clash. Both teams enter the match with defensive concerns and recent inconsistent league performances. Here are the main points:
- New York Red Bulls have conceded multiple goals in three of their last five matches, exposing vulnerabilities in transition.
- New York City FC also struggle defensively on the road, failing to keep clean sheets regularly.
- Red Bulls benefit from home advantage at Sports Illustrated Stadium, where they tend to press higher.
- Both sides have shown strong attacking output recently, with several 4+ goal games combined.
- NYCFC hold a slight historical edge in this derby, winning most of the latest meetings.
- Potential fatigue from a congested MLS schedule could affect pressing intensity in the second half.
- Key attacking players on both sides are in form and likely to influence the outcome.
- Red Bulls need to address their poor away results when translating form to cup pressure.
Free Tips on New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC
This section provides practical, data-driven advice to help you evaluate the upcoming Hudson River Derby more effectively. Drawing from the teams’ recent form, head-to-head trends, and specific match conditions, these tips highlight factors that often decide outcomes in high-stakes cup ties like this one. While both clubs have shown attacking flair, their defensive issues and the knockout format make certain angles particularly relevant.
- Home advantage on artificial turf: Sports Illustrated Stadium features a fast artificial surface that usually favors the home side’s high-pressing style. Red Bulls tend to exploit the quicker ball movement here, while NYCFC have historically struggled to adapt their passing game in this venue.
- Recent defensive fragility of both teams: Both sides have failed to keep a clean sheet in most of their last five matches and have been involved in several high-scoring games. This increases the likelihood of an open contest where individual errors can quickly shift momentum.
- Red Bulls’ strong record in elimination matches: Historically, New York Red Bulls have dominated NYCFC in knockout scenarios, especially at home in the U.S. Open Cup. This psychological and statistical edge can boost confidence and intensity under pressure.
- Congested schedule and potential fatigue: With a busy MLS calendar, both teams have played multiple matches in quick succession. Late substitutions and reduced pressing intensity in the second half could open spaces, particularly benefiting the side that manages its squad rotation better.
- Away struggles for NYCFC: New York City FC have found it difficult on the road recently, conceding regularly and failing to convert chances consistently. Their record in derbies away from home further complicates their task in this Round of 16 tie.
$ 0.00
$ 0.00
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC Match Prediction
This derby is likely to be open and competitive, with both teams showing attacking intent but defensive frailties. Given the home advantage and Red Bulls’ need to bounce back after recent heavy defeats, they start as slight favorites. However, NYCFC’s ability to score in derbies makes a draw or narrow away win entirely possible.
New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC odds reflect a relatively balanced contest, with value potentially available on goals given the high-scoring trend in recent H2H and current form of both teams. The most probable outcome is a narrow Red Bulls win or a high-scoring draw, but the match remains unpredictable due to the knockout nature and rivalry factor. Expect end-to-end football with chances at both ends.
Our Prediction: New York Red Bulls 2-1 New York City FC
| Prediction Type | Prediction | Odds |
| Match Result | New York Red Bulls Win | 2.26 |
| Total Goals | Over 2.5 Goals | 1.64 |
| Both Teams To Score | Yes | 1.55 |
You can place your bet on the New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC match at bc.game.
