Uncovering the Premier League’s Hidden Value: The League’s Most Undervalued Players

Close-up of Emile Smith Rowe, Arsenal's dynamic midfielder.

In the world of football, especially in a high-profile league like the Premier League, the topic of player salaries is always a hot subject. While it’s common knowledge that Premier League stars are among the highest earners in sports globally, there are instances where players’ contributions to their teams significantly outweigh their earnings. This article delves into each Premier League club, highlighting the players who, despite their lower salaries compared to their teammates, are delivering outstanding performances.

Arsenal: Emile Smith Rowe’s Understated Earnings

  • Weekly Salary: £40,000
  • Performance Overview: Despite battling injuries, Smith Rowe’s impact, especially in the 2021-22 season with 10 league goals and several assists, is noteworthy. His salary is modest in comparison to teammates earning over £100,000 weekly.

Aston Villa: Alex Moreno’s Value Exceeds Pay

  • Weekly Salary: £35,000
  • Current Status: Post-recovery from a hamstring injury, Moreno is poised to return to form, having made a significant impact in the previous season. His current earnings seem modest, especially when compared to Aston Villa’s backup goalkeeper earning £50,000 weekly.

Bournemouth: Antoine Semenyo’s Growing Influence

  • Weekly Salary: £20,000
  • Team Contribution: Semenyo, a key scorer only second to Dominic Solanke, earns notably less than the team’s average of £36,900. His potential for a new contract seems likely given his performance.

Brentford: Ivan Toney’s Surprising Salary

  • Weekly Salary: £20,000
  • Remarkable Performance: Toney’s unchanged contract since Brentford’s promotion means he’s still on a Championship wage. His significant contribution to the team has attracted attention from top clubs.

Brighton: Jan Paul van Hecke’s Modest Pay

  • Weekly Salary: £5,000
  • In Context: Van Hecke, despite not being the top choice, earns less than some League One players, highlighting the disparity in his pay.

Burnley: Jordan Beyer’s Incredibly Low Earnings

  • Weekly Salary: £3,000
  • Role Significance: As a key player under Vincent Kompany, Beyer’s earnings are astonishingly low. This salary seems like a system glitch considering his importance to the team.

Chelsea: Conor Gallagher’s Rising Star

  • Weekly Salary: £50,000
  • Team Impact: Gallagher’s consistent starts in Premier League matches for Chelsea this season point to his value, making his current wage seem relatively low.

Crystal Palace: Tyrick Mitchell’s Underwhelming Wages

  • Weekly Salary: £40,000
  • Comparison: Despite starting every game for Palace this season, Mitchell’s earnings are lower than 15 other players in the squad.

Everton: Dwight McNeil’s Growth and Future Prospects

  • Weekly Salary: £25,000
  • Team Evolution: With his development since joining from Burnley, McNeil’s wage is expected to increase soon, especially considering the average wage at Everton is £63,300.

Fulham: Tim Ream’s Veteran Value

  • Weekly Salary: £30,000
  • Experience and Contribution: Ream, a veteran with over 300 appearances for Fulham, is one of their lowest-paid players. His start in most of this season’s games underscores his value versus earnings.

Liverpool: Luis Diaz’s Comparative Earnings

  • Weekly Salary: £55,000
  • Performance Analysis: Diaz’s salary at Liverpool, while substantial, is less than many of his teammates’. His top-level performance makes him a candidate for a future wage increase.

Luton Town: Alfie Doughty’s Earnings Versus Performance

  • Weekly Salary: £7,500
  • Remarkable Contribution: Doughty’s relatively low wage is highlighted by his impressive chance creation, ranking high among Premier League players.

Manchester City: Rico Lewis’s Emerging Talent

  • Weekly Salary: £25,000
  • Future Potential: Lewis, an academy product, shows promise alongside Man City’s superstars. His recent England squad call-up by Gareth Southgate indicates a bright future.

Manchester United: Hannibal Mejbri’s Lowest Earnings

  • Weekly Salary: £5,000
  • Contractual Situation: As the lowest-paid player in the United squad, Mejbri’s future at Old Trafford remains uncertain, with the club holding an option to extend his contract.

Newcastle: Callum Wilson’s Goal-Scoring Value

  • Weekly Salary: £46,000
  • Scoring Efficiency: Wilson’s impressive goal rate in the Premier League makes his current salary a bargain for Newcastle.

Nottingham Forest: Anthony Elanga’s Positive Impact

  • Weekly Salary: £25,000
  • Season Performance: Elanga’s contributions since joining Forest suggest a potential wage increase is due.

Sheffield United: Wes Foderingham’s Goalkeeping Prowess

  • Weekly Salary: £12,500
  • Defensive Contribution: Foderingham, with the most saves in the Premier League, is significantly underpaid compared to his peers and teammates.

Tottenham: Pape Matar Sarr’s Growth Under Ange Postecoglou

  • Weekly Salary: £10,000
  • Team Role: Sarr’s consistent performance in Tottenham’s matches signals a likely future wage increase.

West Ham: Vladimir Coufal’s Consistency Overlooked

  • Weekly Salary: £35,000
  • Team Role and Value: Coufal’s steady performance over several seasons contrasts with his salary, which is less than half the team average.

Wolves: Rayan Ait-Nouri’s Rising Profile

  • Weekly Salary: £10,000
  • Comparative Earnings: As a regular starter, Ait-Nouri’s current earnings are notably lower than the team’s average.

In conclusion, while these Premier League players earn significant sums, their contributions often surpass their financial compensation, making them the most underpaid players in their respective clubs. As the season progresses, it will be interesting to see how their performances influence their future earnings.

Luis Diaz sitting on the Liverpool bench during a match.

Comparative Analysis: The Premier League’s Most Underpaid Players

To provide a clearer overview of the wage discrepancies, here’s a comparative table showcasing each player’s weekly salary against their performance and team role:

ClubPlayerWeekly SalaryPerformance Overview
ArsenalEmile Smith Rowe£40,000Impressive impact with 10 league goals despite injuries.
Aston VillaAlex Moreno£35,000Significant impact in the second half of the last season.
BournemouthAntoine Semenyo£20,000Key scorer for the team, earning less than the team average.
BrentfordIvan Toney£20,000High performance on a Championship wage, attracting top clubs.
BrightonJan Paul van Hecke£5,000Solid performance despite being one of the lowest-paid in the league.
BurnleyJordan Beyer£3,000Key role under Vincent Kompany with astonishingly low earnings.
ChelseaConor Gallagher£50,000Key player under Mauricio Pochettino, starting all matches.
Crystal PalaceTyrick Mitchell£40,000Starter in every game but earns less than 15 other squad members.
EvertonDwight McNeil£25,000Continued development since arrival, below average team wage.
FulhamTim Ream£30,000Veteran defender with over 300 club appearances, undervalued wage.
LiverpoolLuis Diaz£55,000Top performer, earning less than several teammates.
Luton TownAlfie Doughty£7,500High chance creation rate with a comparatively low wage.
Manchester CityRico Lewis£25,000Promising talent, recently called up to the England squad.
Manchester UnitedHannibal Mejbri£5,000Lowest-paid player in the squad with an uncertain future.
NewcastleCallum Wilson£46,000Exceptional goal rate, making his salary a bargain for the club.
Nottingham ForestAnthony Elanga£25,000Impressive season performance, potential for a wage increase.
Sheffield UnitedWes Foderingham£12,500Most saves in the Premier League, significantly underpaid.
TottenhamPape Matar Sarr£10,000Consistent performer, likely to see a future wage increase.
West HamVladimir Coufal£35,000Consistent over several seasons, earning less than half the team average.
WolvesRayan Ait-Nouri£10,000Regular starter, earning considerably less than team’s average.

This table highlights the often overlooked aspect of football finance, where even within the high-earning environment of the Premier League, discrepancies in player compensation exist, sometimes not reflecting the true value and contribution of the players.

You Would Also Like
About the Author

Born in Liverpool in 1984, Ian Fletcher, a distinguished betting expert, attained a Master’s in Sports Analytics from the University of Manchester in 2010. Between 2011 and 2019, he was engaged with various English football clubs, focusing on tactical analysis and player performance metrics. Fletcher has contributed to 12 academic papers, emphasizing the role of game tempo and set-piece efficiency. In 2020, he transitioned into the realm of journalism. Presently, Fletcher authors in-depth analytical pieces on football, exploring game dynamics and team strategies, and his expertise is sought after by numerous sports platforms.

Leave your comment
Everybody will see your comment