Phil Foden has reportedly agreed a major new contract with Manchester City, despite growing debate over whether he should leave the club in search of a fresh start.
The England international’s current deal was due to expire next season, but the new agreement is expected to keep him at the Etihad for the long term. The decision has surprised some supporters, especially given his reduced role under Pep Guardiola in recent months.
Fans question whether Foden should stay
Some fans believe Foden’s career has stalled at City. After once being viewed as one of English football’s brightest attacking talents, he has found regular starts harder to come by this season.
Supporters critical of the new deal argue that he may need a different environment, more freedom and a guaranteed central role to rediscover his best level.
Limited starts have increased the debate
The reaction has been shaped by Foden’s lack of playing time. Since the start of February, he has started only two of City’s last 14 matches in all competitions.
For a player of his reputation, that has led to questions over whether signing a new contract is the right move, especially with the World Cup approaching.
Form has dipped since his best season
Foden’s performances have also come under scrutiny. After winning the Premier League Player of the Season award in 2023/24, his output has not matched those heights.
Last season, he scored 10 goals and provided six assists in 45 games. This campaign, he has 10 goals and five assists in 46 appearances so far.
World Cup place no longer guaranteed
Foden remains in Thomas Tuchel’s England plans, but his place for the World Cup is no longer seen as automatic.
He was included in the latest squad for friendlies against Uruguay and Japan, yet criticism of his recent England performances has led to calls for other players to be preferred.
City still appear committed to him
Despite the concerns, the new contract signals that Manchester City still believe in Foden’s long term value.
For Foden, the challenge now is clear. He must turn that backing into performances, win back a regular place and prove that staying at City is not a comfortable choice, but the right one for his career.
