Manchester derby: City and United share goalkeeper dilemma

City’s choice: Donnarumma or Trafford?

Manchester City have a new name in their squad with the arrival of Gianluigi Donnarumma. The Euro 2020 hero and two-time Yashin Trophy winner provides immediate competition for James Trafford, who only joined from Burnley in July. City have faced more shots on target than any other side in the Premier League this season, and Donnarumma’s proven shot-stopping could be crucial against a United attack that leads the league in attempts.

United’s reshuffle after Onana exit

Manchester United’s summer signing Senne Lammens from Royal Antwerp now stands as the most likely option following Andre Onana’s confirmed loan move to Trabzonspor. Altay Bayindir, who has been heavily criticised in recent performances, remains another option for Ruben Amorim, but pressure is mounting for a change in goal.

🔥Bet of the Day🔥
Jupiler Pro League
PREDICTIONS
12.09.2025
18:45 GMT+0
Standard Liège vs KV Mechelen Prediction, Odds, Betting Tips – Jupiler Pro League 12/09/2025
💰 Get a 300% Bonus 💰
Bet Now

Big decisions for Guardiola and Amorim

Pep Guardiola must weigh the balance between Donnarumma’s elite experience and questions about his fit in City’s build-from-the-back style. Meanwhile, Amorim faces whether to stick with Bayindir or hand a derby debut to Lammens, whose arrival on deadline day was designed to solve United’s long-standing goalkeeping issues.

High stakes at the Etihad

Both clubs enter Sunday’s derby with identical dilemmas: whether to trust their current No.1 or give a debut to a new recruit on one of the Premier League’s biggest stages. With City needing reliability under pressure and United desperate to steady their defence, the goalkeeper selection could define the latest chapter in Manchester’s fierce rivalry.

About the Author

Born in London in 1986, Samuel Gray is a distinguished betting expert with a Master’s in Sports Analysis from the University of Leeds, obtained in 2011. From 2012 to 2019, he worked closely with multiple athletic organizations, specializing in performance metrics across various common sports. Gray has authored 15 academic papers, predominantly on the optimization of training regimes and injury prevention. Transitioning from research in 2020, Gray began a journalism career. He now pens analytical pieces about the nuances of common sports and contributes regularly to several sports-focused platforms, shedding light on contemporary tactics and athlete assessments.

Leave your comment
Everybody will see your comment