Liverpool advanced in the FA Cup third round with a 4-1 win over Barnsley, but supporter reactions show mixed feelings. Many viewed the scoreline as flattering given the overall display against lower-league opposition.
Fans highlighted four well-taken goals but criticised a lack of intensity, slow transitions and complacency. Some expressed concern over Arne Slot’s ability to improve the team quickly.
Negative views from supporters
Darren felt the result flattered Liverpool, pointing to limited clear chances against a tiring Barnsley side. He noted a lack of pace in transitions and urged Slot to speed up the team before time runs out.
Geoff described the performance as insipid despite the goals, saying the outfield play lacks bite in attack and positivity in defence. He said the new system has yet to gel and confidence remains low against stronger teams.
Kate praised the quality of the four goals but called Dominik Szoboszlai’s mistake stupid and avoidable, making the game nervy. She added that Barnsley played well and Liverpool’s dominance did not match the score.
Jack called the win unconvincing, comparing it unfavourably to Manchester City’s dominant display against similar opposition. He questioned the finishing from expensive attackers and said Barnsley deserved more.
Alan labelled the display slow, sloppy and disrespectful, saying Liverpool make simple wins hard through self-inflicted problems. He finds it painful to watch consistently now.
John described the match as shocking, pedestrian and boring, warning that Slot must go if things do not change soon, though he doubts it will happen due to the appointment link with Richard Hughes.
Positive and balanced takes
George took a more optimistic view, calling it a good result despite possession without enough goals. He highlighted Jeremie Frimpong’s threatening runs into the box, better crosses and Rio Ngumoha’s impact against defenders. He sees the team as a work in progress with signs of improvement and urged fans to keep faith.
