Manchester United was left frustrated after a controversial VAR decision led to their loss against West Ham at the London Stadium. United was heading for a 1-1 draw when Matthijs de Ligt was adjudged to have fouled Danny Ings in the penalty area. Although referee David Coote initially dismissed the penalty claim, VAR official Michael Oliver recommended a review. After reconsideration, Coote awarded the penalty, which Jarrod Bowen converted, securing West Ham’s victory in stoppage time. This marked United’s fourth defeat in nine Premier League games.
Premier League’s Statement
The Premier League clarified through its Match Centre account: “VAR deemed there was sufficient contact on Ings’ lower leg and recommended an on-field review.” The referee, therefore, overturned his initial decision, awarding the penalty that ultimately decided the game.
Ten Hag’s Reaction
Manchester United’s manager, Erik ten Hag, openly criticized the VAR process, emphasizing inconsistencies. He questioned VAR’s interference, especially given past decisions where similar incidents went unaddressed. Ten Hag’s critique focused on the VAR process rather than individuals, though he expressed frustration over the impact these decisions had on United’s game outcomes.
Coaches and Players Respond
First-team coach Darren Fletcher also voiced his displeasure, reportedly labeling the situation as inconsistent and a “joke.” On the other hand, West Ham’s Jarrod Bowen supported the penalty call, sharing that he felt the decision was fair upon review.
Alan Shearer’s Verdict
Former player Alan Shearer sided with Manchester United, calling it an “awful decision” and questioning why VAR intervened in the play. His opinion echoed the sentiments of many fans, who felt that United was unfairly penalized.
The controversial VAR decision continues to fuel debate around VAR’s role in Premier League matches, with calls for clearer and more consistent officiating standards.
